Craft

Prose rules

Prose rules are a player's own rules for how the Game Master's replies are written: "No em dashes", "Narrate in second person, present tense", "Never use the word tapestry". They are enforced. After the GM has written a reply, a separate pass checks it against each rule that is on and rewrites what breaks one before the player reads it. The story is already decided by then: the pass changes how a reply is written, never what happens.

Prose rules are experimental, off until a player turns them on, and work only in games on GM Harness 2 (see GM engines).

How it is used

A turn with prose rules on goes in three steps:

  1. The GM plays the turn. It reads the game, rolls and updates records, as on any turn.
  2. The GM writes its reply. This is a draft the player doesn't see.
  3. A rewrite applies the rules. The draft is checked against every rule that is on. If none is broken it is shown as written. If one is, the reply is rewritten to follow the rules, and the player reads the result.

Around those:

  • The GM never sees the rules. They are not in its prompt, so they take none of its attention, and it never learns the pass exists. It does read the rewritten reply as its own on later turns, so its writing drifts toward the rules over a game.
  • The rewrite changes wording only. It is told to keep the facts, the meaning and who says what. A character's line can be reworded but must still mean the same thing, and words that matter as words (a password, something read aloud) stay as they are.
  • The rewrite knows only the turn. It sees the player's message, the last couple of exchanges and the reply. It doesn't know the world or remember the game.
  • Nothing checks the rewrite. It is used whenever it comes back as readable passages. One that comes back blank or unreadable is tried once more, and after that the reply is shown as the GM wrote it. Its instructions are what hold it to the GM's story, so a rule that can only be met by changing the story can change it (see Mistakes).
  • The player's rules win. Where a world's GM instructions ask for something a player's rule cuts (roll numbers in the story), the rule wins: the player chose it.

What it costs

  • The reply arrives all at once. It can't be shown word by word, because it isn't final until the pass is done. The turn takes longer, by several seconds more when the reply is rewritten. The screen says the GM is writing, then that prose rules are being applied.
  • 0.5 energy a turn, shown as its own line, "Prose rules", in the turn's cost. It is charged whether or not the reply was rewritten, and on turns a plan or a free model otherwise covers. A turn where the pass failed is not charged, and neither is a game with enforcement on and no rule on. See Energy and credits.

Changing prose rules

A player keeps one list of rules on their account, and each game has its own copy. Turning enforcement on in a game for the first time copies the owner's account list into it. After that the game's rules are changed for that game alone, and turning enforcement off and on keeps them. Only the game's owner can change them.

  • Your rules: Settings › Experimental, in the Prose rules card. Turn Craft's rules on or off, edit one, or add your own with New rule.
  • In a game: the game's Player Preferences, under Prose rules. Turn on Enforce prose rules and accept the slower turn and the fee. The rules listed there are that game's own.
  • What it did: a reply's menu, Inspect turn. For a turn that ran with prose rules on, the last section says the reply passed, or shows it before and after with the changed words marked.

Craft's rules

Craft ships 12 rules, all off until the player turns one on. None is on by default because players want opposite things: some want plain literal prose and some want it rich and figurative. A rule kept as Craft wrote it picks up better wording when Craft improves it; an edited one keeps the player's text.

Rule What it says
Say what it is Say what something is or does. Don't say what it isn't first.
Bad: It wasn't fear. It was recognition.
Good: She knows his face.
No figures of speech No similes or metaphors, and nothing acts that can't: people and creatures act; rooms, light, silence and feelings don't.
Bad: Silence presses in like a held breath. The door watches you.
Good: Nobody speaks. The door is shut.
No sayings or closing lines No sayings, morals or lines that sum up the scene. End on the last thing that happens.
Bad: Some debts are never paid. And so the night ends.
Good: He pockets the coin and leaves.
No vague words Don't write "something", "somehow", "seems", "almost" or "for a moment". Name the thing, or cut the word.
Bad: Something in his voice seems almost afraid.
Good: His voice shakes.
No game numbers Don't write game numbers in the story: dice rolls and their totals, a roll's verdict, hit points, health, or a running total of the player's money. Tell what the roll did in the story.
Bad: Roll: 17. Success! HP: 12 → 7.
Good: Your blade opens his arm, and he drops the torch.
No em dashes No em dashes.
Second person, present tense Narrate in second person, present tense: the player's character is always "you".
Bad: Kaelen opened the door and stepped inside.
Good: You open the door and step inside.
Show feelings Don't name a feeling or say what a look or a moment means. Show what the person does or says.
Bad: He is ashamed. His glance holds a lifetime of regret.
Good: He looks at the floor.
Full sentences Write full sentences. No runs of fragments for effect.
Bad: Cold. Dark. Waiting.
Good: The room is cold and dark.
No closing question Don't end by asking the player what they do, and don't list options for them.
Bad: What do you do?
Don't restate tool calls Do not restate details presented in tool calls. The player sees each tool call's result on screen as a card (a roll, a contract, an item). Narration continues from the card and moves the story on; it never copies, lists or retells what the card shows.
Bad: A card fills the screen. Objective: raise her trust. Reward: 60 credits.
Good: The panel chimes, and a new contract fills the screen.
Words to avoid Never use these words: tapestry, testament, symphony, ozone, palpable.

"Don't restate tool calls" is checked only on a turn where the player was shown a card (a roll, an item, a contract).

Doing it well

  • Rules about how the writing reads. A rule works when the rewrite can follow it by cutting or rewording what the GM wrote: punctuation, banned words, person and tense, sentence habits, figures of speech, how a reply ends.
  • One habit per rule, in a sentence. Then a "Bad:" line that breaks the rule and a "Good:" line that follows it. The check reads both.
  • Say what to write, where you can. "Narrate in second person, present tense" is checked more reliably than "Don't use third person".
  • Turn on few. Each rule on is one more thing the rewrite must hold to, and long replies keep a few rule-breaking sentences when many are on. Start with the two or three habits that bother you most.
  • Speech has its own rules. A rule about how characters talk ("Characters speak in plain modern English") is checked against what they say. Every other rule is checked against the narration only, so it can't flatten a character's voice.
  • Voice goes in GM instructions. Tone, style, length and detail have to be in the writing from the start. Name the style there, and keep prose rules for the exact habits: see GM Instructions.

Mistakes

A rule that asks for anything beyond rewording is ignored, or the rewrite bends the story to meet it. These belong in GM instructions:

  • A rule about what happens. "Mages should always stand behind martial types", "NPCs should refuse the player more often". The story is decided before the pass runs.
  • A rule about what the GM does. "Always create a file for each new character" is an action, not writing.
  • A length. "Keep replies under 150 words" can only be met by cutting part of the story, and the rewrite may cut it. Use the Response length player option.
  • A tone or richer detail. "Write in a dark, gritty tone with rich detail": the rewrite can't invent what the GM didn't write.
  • A format. Headers, a block for thoughts or a layout for speech collide with the way Craft shows who is speaking.
  • A rule that depends on the scene. "Short sentences in a fight" has nothing to tell the rewrite which scene this is.
  • Expecting it on the original GM. A game on GM Harness 1 can't turn prose rules on.

Limits

  • A rule's text is at most 400 characters, and its name 40.
  • A list holds at most 24 rules, Craft's included, and 12 can be on at once.
  • A world can't ship prose rules. They are not part of its GM instructions, and publishing, releases and game sync never carry them.