Craft

Map audit

Note

Written for AI agents. Orbit and coding agents follow this page when they work on your world. You don't need it to use Craft, but it shows how an agent will approach the job.

This audit checks a world's maps against scene maps and travel maps. It follows how an audit works: start from the world check, report, change nothing. Most of it is numbers the check has already worked out: you read the sampled maps yourself.

What to use from the world check

  • Findings about maps, exits, tokens and game starts.
  • Numbers: scene and travel maps, scene maps with an exit or linked location, crowded maps, maps with a real scale, complete game starts.
  • Samples: the maps and the game start.
  • Features: map scales, exits, linked locations, grids, tokens, the root map, complete game starts.

What to check

  • Scales first. If most maps have no real scale, say so before anything else: Craft tells scene maps from travel maps by scale, so without it the other map numbers are guesses.
  • Scene maps lead somewhere. This matters most. Report how many scene maps have an exit or a linked location, as a share of all scene maps (exits, linked locations). A scene map that another map merely draws can be left by going up to that map, but the GM has nothing on it to follow. Report the fully cut-off ones, which nothing draws either, apart: those strand the party.
  • There is somewhere to play. A world with no scene maps, or whose only map is a starter or another world's file, leads the report.
  • There are enough scene maps. If scenes have nowhere small to play, or a game starts on a travel map, say so.
  • Scene maps are simple. Report the crowded ones: more than about six character tokens, or far more areas and pins than a scene uses.
  • Big maps. A world or regional map with more than about 50 things on it is worth splitting by region. Say it lightly: it helps, and it isn't necessary.
  • The basics: a root map, doors with two sides, exits that lead somewhere real, people where they belong.
  • Workarounds: areas used for something other than marking a place, such as lighting (hacks and workarounds).
  • A good game start. At least one start is complete: a starting place, someone to play, an opening, an opening current state and opening notes (game starts).

On the sampled maps, check what numbers can't show: whether the marked spots are the ones a scene would use, whether pins are named as players would say them, whether the exits come out where you'd expect, and whether the buildings the story goes into are places of their own with scene maps (scene and travel maps).

How much each costs

  • High: a cut-off map, which nothing reaches; an exit that arrives nowhere; a game start that opens on a cut-off map or on a different map from its starting place; a locked or secret way that is open on the map.
  • Medium: scene maps that only their parent map draws; a door with one side (check the far side yourself first); crowded maps; a building the story goes into that is no place of its own.
  • Not an issue: the root map having no exits, when its pins lead into the places on it.